Magic Thumbnails vs MakeShorts
Side-by-side comparison · Updated April 2026
| Description | Magic Thumbnails provides an AI service to generate YouTube thumbnails by simply entering a video title and description. The platform, known for its efficiency in creating appealing thumbnails with minimal input, will be shutting down on February 1st, 2024. Users are encouraged to download any necessary thumbnails before this date. The service offers 10 free credits upon signing in, and features a gallery displaying past thumbnails such as 'How To Become More Confident On Camera For YouTube' and 'Build your first mobile app!'. | MakeShorts is an AI-driven platform designed to create social-media-ready short videos from longer YouTube content. Leveraging advanced AI, it allows users to turn videos into engaging short clips quickly, featuring AI-generated clipping, autofocusing, subtitles, and social captions. With different pricing plans, MakeShorts caters to various needs, offering upload minutes and the ability to add logos and get priority support. Free trials are available with no credit card required. |
| Category | Image Generation | Video Editing |
| Rating | No reviews | No reviews |
| Pricing | N/A | Paid |
| Starting Price | N/A | $9/mo |
| Plans | — |
|
| Use Cases |
|
|
| Tags | AIYouTubethumbnailsautomation | AI-driven platformsocial-media-readyshort videosYouTube contentAI-generated clipping |
| Features | ||
| AI-generated thumbnails | ||
| 10 free credits upon signing in | ||
| Simple text and face thumbnail designs | ||
| Gallery of past thumbnails | ||
| Easy-to-use interface | ||
| No design skills required | ||
| Fast thumbnail creation | ||
| Service ending on February 1st, 2024 | ||
| Suitable for various video content | ||
| Encourages immediate downloads prior to shutdown | ||
| AI Clipping for automatic engaging shorts | ||
| Autofocus Cropping for vertical content | ||
| Fast and accurate AI Subtitling | ||
| AI Social Captions for descriptions and hashtags | ||
| Plan options with unlimited shorts downloads | ||
| Logo addition in Plus and Pro plans | ||
| Priority 24/7 Support in Pro plan | ||
| Free trial with no credit card required | ||
| Support for various languages in source videos | ||
| Smart cropping with face detection technology | ||
| View Magic Thumbnails | View MakeShorts | |